Some travelers recommended Amara Cay, highlighting its nice pool, though noting that prices have increased since its inclusion in a hotel portfolio. Casa Morada is also suggested for its upscale ambiance, and Drop Anchor is favored for more of a Keys style stay. The Islander and Kon Tiki are also mentioned as good options by some users.

For those preferring condo rentals, travelers have suggested properties like Little Basin Villas and Futura Yacht Club. These locations are noted for their proximity to local amenities and include access to pools, adding convenience for guests.

It's important to book accommodations through legitimate channels, as many travelers warned against scams related to private rentals. Consulting local realtors or established rental platforms is advised to ensure legality and avoid last-minute cancellations.

According to forum posts, Islamorada offers various types of boat charters, including fishing, snorkeling, and sunset cruises. Private charters are available for personalized experiences, such as the Nauti Limo for private sunset cruises. For group adventures, companies like Robbies Marina and Whale Harbor Marina offer snorkeling and sandbar trips.

Some travelers recommended specific charter companies for their services. For instance, Easy Adventures is noted for offering shorter snorkeling trips of about 2 hours. Another recommendation includes Clearly Unique Charters, although their self-promotion was critiqued by one forum user. For fishing enthusiasts, marinas like Bud n Mary's and Lorelei were suggested for connecting individuals who wish to share a charter.

For snorkeling-specific charters, travelers have called out Robbies Marina using Sundance Water Sports for snorkeling trips. Additionally, Reef Quest Tours received positive reviews for their snorkeling tours, making them a recommended option for exploring underwater sites around Islamorada.