We stayed at one of aunt Jane's house's for a friend's bachelor party. She was an amazing and very friendly person. She help with any of our needs and actually upgraded us to a bigger and better house freegan of charge! I'd highly recommend booking one of her house's if you are visiting Put In Bay! Thanks for everything Jane!
We had a blast. We had a big crew of 15 guys. The house was perfect for us. There was plenty of places to sleep and it was right around where we wanted to be. It was walking distance to everything. The owner and her crew were very nice to us and very personable. I highly reccomend if you wanna be in the action of the island.
Unfortunately, the owner arbitrarily retained our security deposit. She alleged we were over capacity, treating the security deposit as liquidated damages for any perceived 'breach of lease' (her words), rather than protection against damage. I suspect retained deposits are a second source of income for her. Further, we paid the owner $200 to have a noon to 1pm check in. Our rental was not ready until 2:30 or 3pm and the entire early check in fee was retained. The owner stays on the property until very late at night. If you stay here, you are very clearly the next check. Move on.