We have been regular customers of JT's for 5 years and will say it is inconsistent at times, but overall a great pizza. Sadly are no longer considering it as an option. For the second time in less than a month we have tried to call in pick up orders before 8:00 pm. My order today, 5-13-18, was called in at 7:53pm. I was told (after I ordered) that they would be closing in 5 minutes and if I couldn't get there by then they would not make the order. My first thought was to suggest to the girl answering what she could do with herself and hang up... Immaturely I did that and regret my behavior. What I should have said was you can't even complete my order in 5 minutes (1 large 3 topping). Furthermore, when I said I'd like to make a pick up order; disclose your business policy of if you cannot be here by 8:00 then we cannot help you. My wife went through a similar situation a few weeks back. We will now only consider Michelangelo's in Surf City or Homeport in Hampstead. Both have great pizza.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.