Amazing! One of the few pizza places I have ever been to in the past decade I would come back to with my own money. I make my own pizzas frequently and feel weird spending big wallet pads for cheap ingredients, compared to other cuisines, even for great service, atmosphere, and unique pies. I can happily say Pizza Uncommon strikes a rare chord for the Lafayette area serving up original dishes and amazing combinations of flavors. We have had two specialty pizzas here now and both treated the tastebuds right. I somehow forgot to write a review in my food coma. Can highly recommend to all especially gluten and dairy free diets, save up and dive in!

YUM. We came here on a recommendation, and we’re so glad we did. This place is a little out of the way, but the pizza is FANTASTIC! I assume they have delivery, but we ate in the restaurant. We had three different kinds of pizza. My favorite was shiitake mushroom with arugula and truffle oil. It was incredible. The restaurant itself is very no frills, but it was perfect for a pizza place. Waitstaff was very friendly, and we really enjoyed our meal. The black cherry soda was good too!

We stopped here a year ago while we were on our way home from a gold tournament at Purdue (2022) . We are gluten free and vegan and they had options.

Hands down THE BEST PIZZA EVER!!! Even my gluten free and vegan family said it was some of the best pizza. You can’t even tell the difference. I have never had anything like it in a gluten free crust.

We drove 40 minutes out of our way today then had an hour drive back home. $250 later we had GF and vegan pizza, breadsticks, and chocolate chips cookies (some of the best cookies too…even 18yr old boys think so)!

What a treat. We could eat here once a week. (This time we ordered 4 large pizzas-the white Bianca (new fav), Thai (No chicken), Buffalo (No chicken), BBQ (no chicken)

Super nice and personable staff too 💕

I said we would give this place another try, and I'm so glad we did. The next time I placed an online order, the owner recognized my name from Yelp (eek!) and offered to give me a gift card when I picked up. I insisted it wasn't necessary, but I did appreciate the offer. He also said that after reading my previous review he held a training day for the staff to ensure quality control. That really impressed me. But ... how would the pizza taste this time?

In a word, excellent. Both of our pies were perfectly cooked and not overdone. This time we tried the Cuban Cobb and the Sweet Piggy. Both were delightful. Garlic cheesy sticks were awesome, again.

Although reading other reviews ... it looks like burnt crusts are still an issue. Guess we got lucky this time.

The crust is crisp yet tender, and we love it. Their ingredients are of better quality than the chains. However, the eat-in experience is rather rustic.