I thought the meals were fine. Okay yes, they were not the greatest, but they definately as bad as some have made out in their reviews.
We really enjoyed all out meals during the time we stayed there. Although I'm only 20yo, I do dine out and some very nice restaurants every now and then and it was comparable with some of those. We had steaks, lobsters, heck, I think almost all of the more expensive items on the menu! To be honest, we did not pay for anything on the trip, so that's why we decided to indulge. However in saying that, the Samoa currency is quite favourable for Aussies and New Zealanders and I think one night we had, like another reviewer, a steak and lobster combo plus 2x entrees each and desert and beer AND wine [lol] and it came to just over 200 Samoan dollars if I remember correctly. This works out to about $100 aussie/nz. This is great value and the food really is enjoyable. Just odn't be picky and realise that Samoa is not as 'developed' as other south pacific destinations. They do their best, and their best was fine by me.
Hopefully you will be able to have breakfast at Avi I Toga each day like we did. That restaurant is down over the breakwall and your 'buffet' breakfast is actually all you can eat fresh cooked ordered food. Fantastic stuff and a great spot to eat breaky whilst feeding the fish with your left over toast crusts! :-) Dinner and lunch down at that restaurant were also nice. The large fale restaurant was beautiful and a nice ambiance for dining.
I reccommend the BBQ night and the Fia Fia night. Both all you can eat and very fun. Fia Fia buffet didn't seem to be as nice as I was hoping, food seemed a little too 'cooked too early in the evening'. However, it is a good time to try lots of different Samoan food like Palisami and Taro [put the Palisami on the Taro, its nicer than plain Taro]. Do go across to Coconuts for a meal. It's a nice restaurant there and the food was worth the short walk. :-)
Have a great time! I'm jealous! But, we're going back in 10 [!] months for just over two weeks, 5 nights at Sinalei I think, so not too long till I'm back at one of my favourite places in the world - coming from a not very travelled 20yo of course! :-P