The crust and cheese was good and the toppings adequate. That is more than you find at most pizza places.
1 - 10 of 44 reviews
Recently moved to Grove, hungry for pizza, called for a take out pizza, Hitman , friendly owners, quaint setting, clean main street location. Will definitely return.
Very reasonable prices for the quality of food you receive! Very pleased! I normally do not like pizza but it was family's pick! I will be returning!
Amazing pizza! the taste was good I was particularly a fan of the crust! I got the Hoffa buried in cheese my my my I do recommend. The staff was nice and attentive, the atmosphere was neat I love the mobster theme I will return
Stopped in for a bite during an overnight trek through the area. Tasty pie. Thin crust done really right. Counter guy was very pleasant about making the pie half vegetarian for me. Steady stream of dine-in and carryout customers. Definitely would visit again.
Goodfellas puts out a really tasty pizza pie and it may be a few pennies more than the competition but it is worth it. The memorabilia in the restaurant is interesting also.
Best pizza in town. Best pizza ever! Reminds me of Godfather's pizza from many a year ago. "The Gangster" is our favorite while my daughter loves the "Hoffa Buried in Cheese". Great crust, great sauce.
If you haven't tried pizza in Grove, you are missing one of the best foods available. Goodfellas has the best thin crust and sauce that is just the right amount. Toppings are fresh every time. Salad is enough for 2 to share. Seating is limited...More
Calzone was so so good!! Priced good to. Not a lot of sitting but that's what made it feel like hometown pizza.