What happened to what I typed before? It was very detailed. Needless to say, I enjoyed the experience.
1 - 10 of 110 reviews
This was by far the worst experience I have ever had. We went into Smitty's after we enjoyed fall fest and was looking forward to a relaxing meal. Unfortunately we did not get that! Our server Austin was awful had an attitude,forgot my husband's beers,stood...More
We get to Evansville to eat maybe every other month and want to make our meal count. Normally we go to the Gerst Haus and have been wanting to try Smiity's. Well we bit the bullet and did, and now the Gerst Haus has competition....More
weekday evening meal. Ordered lasagna. It was oily, salty, and had too much sugar. Also tasted like it had been on the warmer for a week.
My parents and I dined out in the courtyard in a recent warm summer evening. While the noise of an air conditioner or some other large machine near the kitchen was distracting, the fountain and greenery were delightful! Usually there is nice dinner music playing,...More
We have been to Smitty's Italian Steakhouse on several occasions. We went today and my husband and I had ribeye steaks cooked to medium perfection. Our grandaughter had the New York Strip that was equally as good. Our waitress Stephanie was above beyond the best...More
A co-worker recommended this place because he knows I'm a steak-guy. I was not disappointed! Excellent steak! As for the Italian dishes, I was a bit disappointed. The sauce was almost canned-like and very tomato-y. The deco is nice, but a bit warmish in the...More
Was in Evansville for a Baseball tournament. We were recommended this establishment, from the owner of Carson's Brewery. Marinara & Ravioli was amazing, the sauce was so fresh! I had the Chicken Parm, with Alfredo. It was very crispy, & tender. Highly recommend!
Party of eight with reservations on a Tuesday night. Everyone in our party had something different, and it was all very good. Excellent service! The only negative thing I can say is the kitchen vent must have not been working. Mid way through our meal...More
Don't be fooled by the name. Their menu is large with a variety of different dishes, not just Italian. I met a friend for lunch recently and I ordered the salad with baked salmon. I could not believe the size of the piece of salmon....More