After a bunch of visits, having tried the whole menu, the food is great and consistent. Love the Gumbo...
1 - 10 of 161 reviews
This was a more casual atmosphere than the Square Grouper below - a little more trendy with live music. Food & service were very good. Reasonable island prices.
We had dinner at the Square Grouper and decided to go upstairs afterwards. It's a nice low key place to wind down especially after a long day of travel.
Been to My New Joint many times. This is an Amazing place. Tons of beer, wine and other cocktails to select from. Great decor, music, atmosphere. Awesome staff that is right on top of your every need. Just simply an AWESOME place to kick back,...More
Lots of beer and drink selections. Huge hanging pretzel with dipping cheese and two mustards—one hot one VERY hot. Build a shared meal out of time many appetizer size selections. Tacos, steak, oysters, shrimp and grits, Cajun shrimp were all tasty.
Service, music ,food, and atmosphere are all perfect. One of my favorite spots in the keys. Perfect place to gather with friends for a night out.
Love this place! We come here for light fare and drinks. Neat atmosphere. Ray the bartender was awesome- gave us great recommendations when we sat at the bar- fun! Another night our waitress- who we called shorty, the older shorty - was funny, and gave...More
Came here for a light bite, a few cocktails and the excellent craft beer selection. Got lucky and happened to be here when they had excellent live music - The Doerfels. Excellent bartenders and staffx. It was a great night, this place is a must...More
We stopped in after having dinner downstairs at the Square Grouper. The place was bustling but we got a hightop table and sat down to listen to the music and have a cocktail. The acoustics for the music are very poor -- we were unable...More
I am sorry that you were unhappy with our music!! Hopefully you enjoyed your cocktail, your server and maybe indulged in one of our desserts like our fried banana split! The Lounge has it's own sound system for our stereo music, but each musician brings...More