10 Best Hotels Near Long Island Aquarium - TripAdvisor

We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

380 of 674 properties match your filters. Clear all filters

Sort by:

Best Value

Traveller Ranked

Best Value

Lowest price

Distance

List Map

Sort Best Value

Filter

Updating list...

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

US$211

US$200

Hyatt.com

View Deal

Booking.com

US$200

Hotels.com

US$199

Hotelpower.com

US$211

View all 13 deals from US$199

451 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901-2556

0.1 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Right next door from the Long Island Aquarium it made a perfect little getaway for me and my son! Lovely room, clean, pool both indoor and outdoor, work out area, picnic area and all right on Peconic Bay! Can't wa...”

We compared the lowest prices from 13 websites

The Preston House & Hotel

US$289

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$288

Orbitz.com

US$288

Travelocity

US$288

View all 6 deals from US$288

428 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901-2484

0.1 km from Long Island Aquarium

“I recently stayed at The Preston House & Hotel with my wife while attending a wedding at the Long Island Aquarium. From the moment we walked in we knew we were going to have a great experience. The front desk...”

We compared the lowest prices from 6 websites

Budget Host East End Hotel

US$143

US$130

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$143

Orbitz.com

US$143

Hotwire.com

US$143

View all 9 deals from US$130

30 Lake Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901-3502

0.8 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Spent one night here with friends. We were here for a golf tournament and needed to crash for about 8 hours. This hotel was conveniently located to the course and about half the price of other local hotels since…”

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

US$121

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$121

Travelocity

US$121

Orbitz.com

US$121

View all 10 deals from US$121

1433 W Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901-3111

3.7 km from Long Island Aquarium

“My wife & I stayed at The Greenview Inn for two nights, August 25th and 26th. We picked Riverview because it was at the junction of the northern and southern parts of Long Island. When we drove up to the motel…”

We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites

Holiday Inn Express East End

US$174

US$162

HIExpress.com

View Deal

Booking.com

US$162

Expedia.com

US$161

Hotelpower.com

US$174

View all 13 deals from US$161

1707 Old Country Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901-4422

3.8 km from Long Island Aquarium

“There were so many things for the kids to do-there's the Long Island Aquarium, Quogue Wildlife Refuge(not too far from the hotel), Long Island Canoe/kayak rentals(also close to the hotel)-the Tanger Outlets and lo...”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special OfferBook Direct and Save

We compared the lowest prices from 13 websites

Residence Inn Long Island East End

US$165

Booking.com

View Deal

Residence Inn

US$165

Expedia.com

US$165

Hotels.com

US$165

View all 8 deals from US$165

2012 Old Country Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901-3149

5.1 km from Long Island Aquarium

“2-bedroom suite had plenty of room for our family of 3 adults. Cheaper than booking 2 separate rooms at area hotels. Interaction with family works better in shared space. Outdoor pool small but refreshing after…”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special OfferMember Rates

We compared the lowest prices from 8 websites

Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead

US$160

GardenInn.com

View Deal

Booking.com

US$160

galahotels.com

US$157

Hotelpower.com

US$191

View all 13 deals from US$157

2038 Old Country Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901-3149

5.1 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Also a short drive to the Long Island Aquarium, Splish Splash (didn't go here), Briermere Farms.”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special OfferDouble Points, Every Stay

We compared the lowest prices from 13 websites

Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End

US$200

US$181

HotelIndigo.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$180

Booking.com

US$181

Hotelpower.com

US$200

View all 13 deals from US$180

1830 W Main St, Route 25, Riverhead, NY 11901-3113

5.5 km from Long Island Aquarium

“The food was delicious, good ambiance, clean grounds and comfortable beds. Only suggestion is to have a go to list for the guest with recommendations on things to do in the area according to the time and day of…”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special OfferBook Direct and Save

We compared the lowest prices from 13 websites

The Quogue Club

US$329

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$329

Agoda.com

US$329

Orbitz.com

US$329

View all 8 deals from US$329

47 Quogue St, Quogue, NY 11959-9500

12.1 km from Long Island Aquarium

“My boyfriend and I stayed here last weekend for our 5 year anniversary. The hotel is absolutely gorgeous! There were very few guests due to the fact that it's February, and not their busy season. It was nice…”

Hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 8 websites

The Inn and Spa at East Wind

US$160

Booking.com

View Deal

Priceline

US$160

TripAdvisor

US$160

Expedia.com

View all 9 deals from US$160

5720 Route 25A, Wading River, NY 11792-2033

13.9 km from Long Island Aquarium

“This is a beautiful hotel that is just a bit outdated, so it can have a bit of a creepy vibe. It has an indoor pool which is smart considering three quarters of the year you can't swim outside. The grounds are...”

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

Colonial Shores Resort

US$173

Hotels.com

View Deal

Booking.com

US$162

Expedia.com

US$173

Orbitz.com

US$173

View all 8 deals from US$162

83 W Tiana Rd, Hampton Bays, Southampton, NY 11946-3699

11.5 km from Long Island Aquarium

“I stayed in a small room that was half of a cottage. It was clean and adequately furnished with a small table, chairs & 2 beds. The bed was super comfortable. The room had very basic kitchen accommodations - a…”

We compared the lowest prices from 8 websites

Bowen's by the Bays

Hotels.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$200

Booking.com

US$200

Agoda.com

US$200

View all 10 deals from US$200

177 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, Southampton, NY 11946-2305

11.2 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Our family of four stayed in the studio which was perfect size. The room was comfortable and had everything we needed the make our stay easier with two small children. The grounds are beautiful and very well...”

We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites

Hotels.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$173

Booking.com

US$173

Agoda.com

US$173

View all 10 deals from US$173

53 W Tiana Rd, Hampton Bays, Southampton, NY 11946-3626

11.3 km from Long Island Aquarium

“I came here for a Bachlorette Party and was pleasantly surprised by the hotel. The rooms were modern and clean. Although expensive, but it is expected for the location. Right on the water, they had a pool and...”

We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites

US$222

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$222

Priceline

US$222

Hotwire.com

US$222

View all 9 deals from US$222

16 Penny Ln, Hampton Bays, Southampton, NY 11946-3211

14.2 km from Long Island Aquarium

“The Drake Inn is exactly as advertised - maybe even a bit more special than that. Rooms are clean and new, with nice touches such as the delivered croissants in the morning. The office keeps limited hours, but…”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special OfferEarly Bird Special!

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

Bay Watch Hotel & Marina

US$278

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$278

Agoda.com

US$278

Hotwire.com

US$278

View all 10 deals from US$278

72 Foster Ave, Hampton Bays, NY 11946, Hampton Bays, Southampton, NY 11946-3226

14.5 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Amazing place to get out of your rutine and have a good enjoyable vacations, just love it.Service was excellent, swimming pool are good, location is perfect. Close to the best restaurants and the interes places of...”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special Price20% off room rate

We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites

US$185

Booking.com

View Deal

Agoda.com

US$185

Expedia.com

US$177

Priceline

US$185

View all 9 deals from US$177

300 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY 11968-4109

17.7 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Within walking distance of Shinnecock Hills golf course, this is unlike any hotel I have stayed in previously. Very acceptable rooms with good beds, tv and bathroom. Breakfast is a little basic but this is made up...”

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

US$174

Hotels.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$174

Booking.com

US$177

Travelocity

US$174

View all 8 deals from US$174

1655 County Road 39, Southampton, NY 11968-5254

17.1 km from Long Island Aquarium

“We pulled into the MOTEL we were skeptical but the employee at the front desk was polite and put us into a nice room. It was newly redone with 2 decent size beds and a futon. It worked well for our family’s visit…”

We compared the lowest prices from 8 websites

SpringHill Suites by Marriott Long Island Brookhaven

US$144

Booking.com

View Deal

Hotels.com

US$143

Travelocity

US$143

Orbitz.com

US$143

View all 11 deals from US$143

2 Sawgrass Dr, Bellport, NY 11713-1549

27.5 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Crew sked booked this hotel for us and it’s working out great. Front desk was awesome with room keys ready. Rooms are set up great. Flat screen TV, all the channels plus Netflix access. Bed is comfy and super…”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special OfferMember Rates

Savings alert! 13% below average rates

The price you found is 13% lower than this hotel's average rate of US$166/night.

We analyze rates over a 60 day period, and compare your selection to the average rate of comparable stays to ensure you're getting the best possible deal.

We compared the lowest prices from 11 websites

Southampton Long Island Hotel

US$174

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$174

Priceline

US$174

Hotwire.com

US$174

View all 8 deals from US$174

450 County Road 39, Southampton, NY 11968-5207

20.5 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Motel was clean and quiet. Small rooms with no counter space in the bathroom, smaller beds and no breakfast. Great for one or two nights. A nice option for something a little less expensive in "The Hamptons".”

Special offer

Offers & AnnouncementsBOOK DIRECT TO SAVE 10%

We compared the lowest prices from 8 websites

Southampton Inn

US$300

US$285

Hotels.com

View Deal

Booking.com

US$300

Expedia.com

US$285

Priceline

US$300

View all 10 deals from US$285

91 Hill St, Southampton, NY 11968-5399

22.2 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Our visit to the Southampton Inn was short - only one night. But during that time, we had a great experience. The hotel team was very friendly, and helpful with all of our questions, as first time visitors to…”

We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites

US$295

Booking.com

View Deal

Hotels.com

US$292

Orbitz.com

US$292

Expedia.com

US$292

View all 9 deals from US$292

281 County Road 39a, Route 27, Southampton, NY 11968-5213

22.5 km from Long Island Aquarium

“DO NOT STAY AT CAPRI THIS HOLIDAY WEEKEND. $899/night? Seriously, you will regret it. I stayed last month and it ruined my entire trip to the Hamptons. We left feeling depressed, hungry & tired. All of the...”

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

US$147

US$114

Booking.com

View Deal

ComfortInn

US$114

Expedia.com

US$114

Hotelpower.com

US$147

View all 14 deals from US$114

2695 Route 112, Medford, NY 11763-2521

30.7 km from Long Island Aquarium

“This was a great place to relax between family functions on Long Island. The room was kept clean and comfortable. There was a lovely breakfast included each morning: Continental plus scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage...”

We compared the lowest prices from 14 websites

Shelter Island House

US$195

Official Site

View Deal

Booking.com

US$195

Expedia.com

US$195

Hotels.com

US$195

View all 8 deals from US$195

11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965-2009

30.2 km from Long Island Aquarium

“Had an amazing time at the shelter island house. The accommodations were top notch. The pool was refreshing and the staff was accommodating. We went for a quick weekday getaway and it was just what we needed. We...”

Savings alert! 17% below average rates

The price you found is 17% lower than this hotel's average rate of US$236/night.

We analyze rates over a 60 day period, and compare your selection to the average rate of comparable stays to ensure you're getting the best possible deal.

We compared the lowest prices from 8 websites

Southampton Village Motel

US$363

Booking.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

US$334

Travelocity

US$334

Orbitz.com

US$334

View all 6 deals from US$334

315 Hampton Rd, Southampton, NY 11968-5029

23.3 km from Long Island Aquarium

“My husband and I recently stayed at the Southampton Village Motel, and I cannot say enough nice things about the accommodations, friendliness of the staff, and location of the motel! It is a short bike ride into...”

We compared the lowest prices from 6 websites

The Pridwin Hotel

US$195

Expedia.com

View Deal

Booking.com

US$195

Orbitz.com

US$195

Travelocity

US$195

View all 9 deals from US$195

81 Shore Road, Crescent Beach, Shelter Island, NY 11964

29.0 km from Long Island Aquarium

“The hotel is old!! It’s a lot of money for what you get in terms of style or service, It’s in a beautiful location and has real character but the service is amateurish, but maybe the hotel is going for like laid...”

Hotel website

Special offer

AnnouncementPridwin Fall Season!

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

Fairfield Inn Medford Long Island

US$124

Fairfield Inn

View Deal

Booking.com

US$124

Expedia.com

US$123

Travelocity

US$123

View all 10 deals from US$123

2695 Route 112, Medford, NY 11763-2521

30.7 km from Long Island Aquarium

“This is a great hotel to stay at for a day or a week. The beds are very comfortable with the a/c working wonderful! The breakfast is a lot better than most with eggs, bacon or sausage every day. I would stay...”

Hotel website

Special offer

Special OfferMember Rates

Savings alert! 10% below average rates

The price you found is 10% lower than this hotel's average rate of US$138/night.

We analyze rates over a 60 day period, and compare your selection to the average rate of comparable stays to ensure you're getting the best possible deal.

We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites

US$175

Groupon.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

Orbitz.com

Hotels.com

View all 6 deals from US$175

61600 Route 25, Southold, NY 11971-4740

27.5 km from Long Island Aquarium

“We stayed at Heron Suites for the first time this year after our regular hotel, the Sound View Inn, renovated and sent their rates into the stratosphere while taking away many of their amenities. We're happy that…”

We compared the lowest prices from 6 websites

Sound View Greenport

US$483

US$414

Booking.com

View Deal