Do any hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have a pool?

Popular hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada that have a pool include: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5

What are the best hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada?

Some of the best hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada are: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5

Which hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada offer a gym?

A gym is available to guests at the following hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5 Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5

Which hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have rooms with a private balcony?

A private balcony can be enjoyed by guests at the following hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5 Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5

Which hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have rooms with great views?

These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have great views and are well-liked by travellers: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5

Which hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada are romantic?

These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have been described as romantic by other travellers: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5 Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5

Which hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada are good for families?

Families travelling in Islamorada enjoyed their stay at the following hotels near Alligator Reef Light House: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5

Which hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada allow pets?

These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada generally allow pets: Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5 Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5 La Siesta Resort & Villas - Traveller rating: 4/5 It is always best to call ahead and confirm specific pet policies before your stay.

Which hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have free parking?

These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have free parking: The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5 Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5 Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5

What are some popular hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada with a 3 star rating?

These 3 star hotels received great reviews from other travellers: Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5 Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5 The Caribbean Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5

Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House

Best Hotels Near Alligator Reef Light House, Islamorada

Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House

This historic lighthouse off the east coast of Florida Keys was named after a pirate ship that sank in that location over a century ago. So don't worry, there aren't actually any alligators found here! Today, the now decommissioned lighthouse marks the wreck of the ship and teems with marine life and corals in its crystal clear waters, making it a popular spot for snorkeling. You can get up close to the lighthouse on a boat or jet ski tour, which sometimes also include stops at the nearby sand bars and other spots around Islamorada. – Tripadvisor

Searching hundreds of travel sites to find you the best price

Sort by:

Best Value
Properties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveller ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
Traveller Ranked
Highest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveller reviews.
Distance from Alligator Reef Light House
See properties located closest to the place of interest first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners.

Payments made by partners impact the order of prices displayed. Room types may vary, learn more.

Highest-rated 4-star hotel within 8 km of Alligator Reef Light House
Based on availability on Tripadvisor for 2 February - 3 February
1. La Jolla Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
656 reviews
82216 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
8.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#1 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"My husband and I just returned from our stay at La Jolla in Islamorada. Beautiful, quiet resort, that made us feel like we were one of a very few in residence. The evenings are so peaceful, with a magnificent view..."
2. Amara Cay Resort
Enter dates to see prices
2,163 reviews
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036-3802
6.5 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#2 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"The beach had a amazing view you can even see alligator reef light house."
3. Cheeca Lodge & Spa
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
7,331 reviews
81801 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036-3631
7.3 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#3 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Overall one of the better options in the keys. Resort fee gives you lots of options for onsite activities that are included. Our room was dated and in need of an upgraded appearance and the only real area for..."
4. La Siesta Resort & Villas
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
1,041 reviews
80241 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036-3800
6.5 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#4 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Great location, friendly staff, easy parking and nice waterfront area. My only issue was the garden view room we stayed in could use a deep cleaning. The floors were very dirty, hair left in the tub and everything..."

5. Islander Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
1,198 reviews
82100 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
7.6 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#5 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Absolutely wonderful getaway at the islander resort! The resort and grounds are stunning, all of the rooms have just been totally renovated and are gorgeous. Extensive landscaping is underway and it looks great..."
Visit hotel website
Breakfast included
6. Casa Morada
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
1,363 reviews
136 Madeira Road Mile Marker 82, Islamorada, FL 33036-3615
8.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#6 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"What a Gem in the Keys and especially Islamorada. Lush landscape and very accommodating staff. Nice rooms well equipped. This is our third time there and will come back again. Great location for restaurants as..."
Visit hotel website

7. Pines and Palms Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
859 reviews
80401 Old Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
6.5 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#7 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Such a gorgeous resort. My bungalow was huge, stocked and comfortable. The bed was amazing and top notch, felt like I was sleeping in a cloud! I loved the sandy beach areas, the boat launch was great for taking out..."
8. Chesapeake Beach Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
242 reviews
83409 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036-3526
9.3 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#8 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"This was a wonderful place to relax and watch sunrise every morning, and most importantly Relaxing. Chef Chris was excellent! The rooms are clean We really liked two different swimming pools, one for adults and one..."
9. The Islands Of Islamorada
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
68 reviews
82779 Old Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
8.3 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#9 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Perfect all-ages family escape! Beautiful resort, decor, included amenities, friendly staff, and excellent communication. Easy access to shops and restaurants and tourist attractions though there’s no need to leave..."
Visit hotel website
10. Fisher Inn Resort & Marina
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
399 reviews
84951 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
10.9 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#10 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Fisher Inn has beautiful views, friendly and accommodating staff, a pool and fun games to play like corn hole, ping pong and jenga, and is one of the few places that allows jet skis. They also have kayaks and paddle..."

11. The Moorings Village
Enter dates to see prices
396 reviews
123 Beach Rd, Islamorada, FL 33036-3768
7.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#11 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"My wife and I had stayed here many years ago but had gravitated to the Cheeca when our daughter was with us over the years. Just stayed 3 night over new years with daughter and fiancé in adjoining north and south..."
Breakfast included
12. Hadley Resort & Marina
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
361 reviews
82749 Overseas Hwy., Islamorada, FL 33036
8.3 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#12 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"I had an incredible experience at this hotel so far, and a huge part of that was thanks to the amazing front desk staff, Giselle and Krista! From the moment I walked in, they were warm, welcoming, and incredibly..."
13. Drop Anchor
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
990 reviews
84959 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
10.9 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#13 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Drop Anchor exceeded my expectations!!! It was everything I wanted and more! Such a beautiful place and Daniel was such a great host!!!! The location was perfect. The room was very clean and had everything we..."
14. Bayside Villas by Islander Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
332 reviews
81450 Overseas Highway Mile Marker 81.4, Islamorada, FL 33036
7.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#14 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Our stay at the Bayside Villas was pretty good...but there were a few negatives. First, the good news. The living space and kitchen are spacious and well-equipped. The balcony was great for outdoor dining with a..."
Visit hotel website
This is one of the highest rated properties in Long Key
This is one of the most booked hotels in Long Key over the last 60 days.
15. Lime Tree Bay Resort
Enter dates to see prices
2,126 reviews
68500 Overseas Hwy, Layton, Long Key, FL 33001
20.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
"“Old Keys” facade on otherwise undeveloped stretch of Hywy 1. Modern plantation style buildings behind. Every room (ours spacious and comfy) opening to well tended bayside view with ample rockers, hammocks and..."
Visit hotel website

16. The Caribbean Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
131 reviews
117 South Carroll Street Mile Marker 82, Islamorada, FL 33036
7.5 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#16 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Do not hesitate to book this absolute gem of a resort. My husband and I stayed in the Coconut Palm South "home" and it was spotless and beautifully decorated. The use of bicycles, kayaks, fishing poles etc, are all..."
Visit hotel website
17. Coconut Palm Inn
Enter dates to see prices
1,972 reviews
198 Harborview Dr, Key Largo, FL 33070-2664
20.4 km from Alligator Reef Light House
"THIS PLACE!!!!! I fell in love with this little hidden gem. The coziest little rooms with the most adorable private outdoor area with comfortable chairs, fan and tv right outside your door. AND overlooking the..."
Visit hotel website
18. Coral Bay Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
308 reviews
75690 Overseas Hwy MM 75.5 Bayside, Islamorada, FL 33036-4004
9.7 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#18 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Such a quaint little Awesome resort neselled in a perfect location on Florida Bay....Helpful friendly staff and wonderful accommodations!! We will definitely be back! The resort is aged with character! Just like the..."
This is one of the most booked hotels in Key Largo over the last 60 days.
19. Island Bay Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
997 reviews
92530 Overseas Highway, Tavernier, Key Largo, FL 33070-2758
21.2 km from Alligator Reef Light House
"Our second time staying here. We love this little intimate gem when traveling to the Keys. The rooms are very clean, and the beds are comfortable. The kitchenette is perfect for preparing a little something to eat..."
Visit hotel website
20. Ocean View Inn and Sports Pub
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
224 reviews
84500 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036-3421
10.7 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#20 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"This is a very quaint motel like inn. It’s close to the road but you don’t hear any traffic in your room. . And each room has a private patio in the back that is beautifully landscaped. My husband and I really..."

21. Kon-Tiki Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
207 reviews
81200 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036-3703
7.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#21 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"We arrived late but George was still in reception. He was polite,friendly and informative. The Kon tiki has old florida charm. Our room was upstairs and was clean and comfortable. It had a large comfy bed and had..."
This is one of the most booked hotels in Islamorada over the last 60 days.
22. Three Waters Resort And Marina, Islamorada, A Tribute Portfolio Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
16 reviews
84001 Overseas Highway, Windley Key, Islamorada, FL 33036
10.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#22 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Mercado Morada was fantastic for both breakfast and lunch! The food was delicious, and the servers were all really attentive and friendly. It made for a wonderful dining experience The rooms were absolutely..."
Visit hotel website
This is the closest accommodation to Alligator Reef Light House
23. Sands of Islamorada Hotel
Enter dates to see prices
289 reviews
80051 Overseas Hwy Mile Marker 80, Islamorada, FL 33036-3802
6.4 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#23 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"The sands is absolutely adorable with a beautiful view on the water. I only dropped one star because the mattress was extremely uncomfortable. It’s in a great location with several restaurants and activities close..."
24. Atlantic Bay Resort
Enter dates to see prices
1,170 reviews
160 Sterling Rd, Tavernier, Key Largo, FL 33070-2708
20.9 km from Alligator Reef Light House
"Literally just got here this morning and the front desk Staff “Lilly” was very nice and kind…. The property was being maintained by the maintenance upon arrival to a beautiful view…. Clean and beautiful rooms , NO..."
25. Creekside Inn Islamorada
Enter dates to see prices
578 reviews
90611 Old Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
18.7 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#25 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"Excellent place and service. Perfect location. Boat and pontoon rental possible (boats in excellent condition). Clean rooms. Very friendly personal. Excellent breakfast with fantastic view to canal. And Ronny the..."
26. Caloosa Cove Resort & Marina
Enter dates to see prices
Apartment
273 reviews
73801 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036-4233
11.9 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#26 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"We recently stayed two weeks at Caloosa. It's nicely located at the south end of Islamorada. Restaurants and other amenities are easily within a few minutes' drive. I think the best features are the ocean views..."
Visit hotel website
27. Coconut Cove Resort and Marina
Enter dates to see prices
425 reviews
84801 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036-3418
10.7 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#27 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"I arrived about 9am so my room was not ready yet. ( I didn't expect it to be). The lady at the front desk was very nice and said I could use all the amenities onsite until my room was clean. When I got my room it..."
28. Ocean Pointe Suites at Key Largo by Provident Hotels & Resorts
Enter dates to see prices
2,883 reviews
500 Burton Dr, Tavernier, Key Largo, FL 33070
22.1 km from Alligator Reef Light House
"This place has a lot of potential, but falls a bit short in a few areas. To start, room 4410 really needs a deep clean. The baseboards and corners on the floors are caked with crud that has built up and been ignored..."
29. Lime Tree Bay Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
1 review
68500 Overseas Highway Us 1 Mile Marker 68.5, Layton, Long Key, FL 33001
19.8 km from Alligator Reef Light House
"Great place and attentive staff!!! Quiet and relaxing. My daughter and I needed peace and quiet and this was just that place. No parties, no loud music and the staff made sure of it. This is a very peaceful place. "
30. Smugglers Cove Resort and Marina
Enter dates to see prices
Small Hotel
226 reviews
85500 Overseas Hwy Mile Marker 85.5, Islamorada, FL 33036-3400
11.5 km from Alligator Reef Light House
#30 Best Value of 76 Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House
"I've stopped here several times over the years on my way to and from Key West. Good food in a relaxed (is there any other in the keys?) atmosphere. The last time I stopped, the windows were boarded up. The marina on..."

Showing results 1-30 of 76

Hotels near similar destinations

Anne's Beach Hotels
Read more
Founders Park Hotels
Read more
Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park Hotels
Nature trails and fossilized coral reefs are the highlights of this park.
Read more
Library Beach Park Hotels
Read more
Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park Hotels
Read more
Islamorada County Park Hotels
Read more
Windley Key Hotels
Read more
Whale Harbor Marina Hotels
Read more

Hotels Near Alligator Reef Light House information

Hotels Near Alligator Reef Light House	There are 41 Hotels nearby in Islamorada
Hotels nearby reviews	There are 21,592 reviews on Tripadvisor for Hotels nearby
Hotels nearby photos	There are 20,485 photos on Tripadvisor for Hotels nearby
Nearest accommodation	6.40 km

Frequently Asked Questions about hotels near Alligator Reef Light House

: Popular hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada that have a pool include:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
: Some of the best hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada are:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
: A gym is available to guests at the following hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5
: A private balcony can be enjoyed by guests at the following hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5
: These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have great views and are well-liked by travellers:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
: These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have been described as romantic by other travellers:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5
: Families travelling in Islamorada enjoyed their stay at the following hotels near Alligator Reef Light House:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
: These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada generally allow pets:
Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5
La Siesta Resort & Villas - Traveller rating: 4/5
It is always best to call ahead and confirm specific pet policies before your stay.
: These hotels near Alligator Reef Light House in Islamorada have free parking:
The Moorings Village - Traveller rating: 5/5
Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Cheeca Lodge & Spa - Traveller rating: 4/5
: These 3 star hotels received great reviews from other travellers:
Islander Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Amara Cay Resort - Traveller rating: 4/5
The Caribbean Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5

Best Hotels Near Alligator Reef Light House, Islamorada

Hotels near Alligator Reef Light House

Popular

AwardsTravellers’ Choice Awards winners (including the “Best of the Best” title) are among the top 10% of listings on Tripadvisor, according to the reviews and opinions of travellers across the globe.

Property types

Amenities

Distance from

Traveller rating

Hotel class

Style

Brands

Hotels near similar destinations

Hotels Near Alligator Reef Light House information

Hotels Near Alligator Reef Light House

Hotels nearby reviews

Hotels nearby photos

Nearest accommodation

Awards
Travellers’ Choice Awards winners (including the “Best of the Best” title) are among the top 10% of listings on Tripadvisor, according to the reviews and opinions of travellers across the globe.