We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
The beer was fairly good and interesting. Tried the raspberry beer which had an interesting twist to it. Rose was good even though its a beer place. Liked the benches outside in a quiet area. They have games for kids to play so that's always...More
We stopped here with a group of friends on a beautiful Sunday afternoon. Came by boat, got a ride in the back of a truck from the marina to this unique location. So far so good. However the good times stopped there as the beer...More
Except stop at this little brewery. Their beer is unpasteurized and antibiotic free. Very nice IPA and sour beers on tap. The German pretzel and mustard were fantastic. Don’t miss this little piece of heaven when you’re on the island.
This was part of our Long Island Brewery tour. The best thing about it is the unique location. There was not much of a selection of beer and what we tried we really did not like. One plus is that they have a small food...More
We were hiking around the island for the day and we grabbed lunch at Maria’s next door and ate it, along with some terrific beers, here. It was the perfect midday stop. The owner also gave us advice about places to see on our way...More
We stopped in mid afternoon in a Saturday in October. I asked the bartender if they had flights to sample several beers. He gave me a sarcastic look and said they did not have flights. I then asked if the had a pumpkin beer. He...More
This place could be so nice but it needs attention. Two teenagers (looks like) running the place providing dismissive service. Beers were nice but expensive for the small size they served. Snack food really expensive and so-so. Chips and salsa came straight out of a...More
We love craft breweries and think the SI Craft Brewery would be a great addition to the island, but have so far seen it to be staffed with inattentive and super rude guys...very disappointed...fingers crossed that we see improvement and the brand of kindness more...More
I go to Shelter Island every year with a great group of friends. Last year my friends raved about Shelter Island Craft Brewery and took me for my first visit. We all loved it. The Craft brews were great, and so was the food. Then...More